Jerusalem II Pizza

Located in the heart of Brooklyn at 1312 Avenue J, Jerusalem II Pizza offers an authentic and comforting taste of classic New York-style pizza that feels like a warm nostalgic hug. This pizza restaurant is a true gem for those who appreciate a well-crafted slice and a welcoming neighborhood atmosphere.

Jerusalem II Pizza specializes in hearty, flavorful pies that pay homage to traditional recipes while adding their own delightful twists. Among their menu highlights, the Sicilian Pie stands out as a thick, square slice with a perfectly fluffy crust, balanced by tangy tomato sauce and just the right amount of melted cheese. For those seeking lighter or health-conscious options, the Whole Wheat Plain Pie offers the same delightful flavors crafted with whole wheat flour, ensuring a wholesome experience without compromising taste.

The restaurant also caters to diverse tastes with options like the Vegetable Pie, featuring a colorful medley of mixed peppers and onions, as well as pasta choices such as the creamy yet zesty Penne Ala Vodka with Marinara Sauce and satisfying Baked Ziti, both perfectly portioned and priced to please. To round out your meal, their cold drinks selection, including indulgent milkshakes like Cookies and Cream or classic Vanilla and Chocolate, adds a sweet finish to your dining experience.

The dining atmosphere at Jerusalem II Pizza is a charming throwback to the '90s pizza joints that many remember fondly. As customer Aaron Eliezer Pilchick notes, the curved benches, wall-mounted tables, and gently swirling ceiling fans set a cozy scene, creating an inviting ambiance that enhances the overall experience. This genuine, unpretentious vibe, free from modern glossiness, makes visiting feel like stepping into a beloved local storybook.

Customers consistently praise not only the food quality but also the attentive, friendly service. Monica W shares how her family was "all so impressed" with the lightness of the pizza and the perfect balance of sauce and cheese, making it a hit with both kids and adults alike. Wen Wen emphasizes the breadth of the menu, from soul-satisfying tomato and cheese pies to fresh vegetable offerings and standout dishes like Eggplant Parmigiana and mozzarella sticks. Jerome Cooper highlights the unbeatable value and friendly service, comparing Jerusalem II’s pizza favorably to the more famous—and pricier—options in Brooklyn.

Jerusalem II Pizza thrives as a family-friendly, community-centered spot, where each visit feels more like coming home than just grabbing a meal. Whether you’re craving a personal Mini Pie or a full Sicilian square to share, this pizzeria delivers warmth, flavor, and a slice of genuine Brooklyn spirit with every bite.